Corporate Governance in the Lodging Industry - Study Results of Board Performance in Hospitality
October 13, 2015 1:50am
By: Keith Kefgen | Georgianne Fsadni
But newer concerns have developed in corporate governance and the lodging industry is yet to be a shiny example of best practices. Three points to note which may drive change in 2015-16 are:
Will these issues drive composition and responsibility changes in the board room in the coming years? We certainly think so, as the stakes are just too high.
Similar to our previous studies, we examined and ranked companies in five key areas of corporate governance:
Of the 26 hotel companies and REITS studied, not one group scored perfectly as it relates to size, makeup and independence of the board due to one of the following: an even number of board members, the chairman and CEO functions are not separated, too many insiders on the board, a classified board (terms of greater than one year), and finally, the lack of a formal diversity policy. Click here for an overview of the total scores and the top-performing boards.
With respect to committee structure, the industry fared better with just under 50% of the group achieving perfect score – this means that they have the appropriate committees comprised of independent board members, meet at least four times a year and do not have an executive committee.
Related party transactions remain prevalent in our surveyed group with only nine having absolutely no related transactions (whether approved by the board or not). For some, this is a matter of course due to the nature and history of their existence – such as Ashford and Host. For others, it seems it would be a fairly easy fix – just say no!
In the evaluation and communication bucket, a few observations: all the companies include a policy to conduct annual self-evaluations in their governance documents, some even comment in their proxies that this has been done, yet no one posted the results. Could a best practice going forward be to summarize (respecting the confidentiality of the individual boards) the results of said evaluations and present to shareholders in the proxies?
With regards to communication, very few companies allow the BOD free and clear access to any of the senior management – most do want to control the communication through the CEO. And with respect to the shareholders, most of their communication is reviewed and filtered through the Corporate Secretary. However, we noted that a number of companies are posting “whistle-blower” 24/7 hotlines either on their website, or in their business conduct code. We would like to see these hotlines published clearly in the proxy and on the website as a best practice going forward – versus a number buried within documentation on a tab within in a tab on a website.
Finally as it relates to compensation, more and more companies are moving towards a great percentage of the NEO pay being performance based. Full marks were afforded to only five of the 26 surveyed companies, with the hold up primarily being the lack of a claw-back policy, continued use of gross-up provisions, no stockholder requirements, or no third-party compensation expert used to analyse peer group comps.
Although not part of our formal evaluation this year, it was noted when reviewing the 2015 Proxy Statements, less than half mention succession planning in any meaningful manner; five mention sustainable practices; and only three mention cyber security responsibilities.
Congratulations to Diamond Rock this year, who scored 40 out of a possible 45 points, and Sunstone and Ryman who were directly behind them. More effort in the articulation and monitoring of a board diversity policy was a common weak link. As a comparison, we analysed two Fortune 500 companies that recently won governance awards. PepsiCo recently received the award for Exemplary Shareholder Engagement at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) Governance Services’ 2015 Governance, Risk & Compliance Leadership Awards. Although Pepsi was strong in this area, our analysis determined that their board is too big, their CEO is also Chairman and they had some Related Transactions. Interestingly, Pepsi would have scored 36 in our study.
Navient won the Best Board Diversity Initiative award in the same NYSE program. While this is commendable, they unfortunately had many of the same issues as Pepsi. Navient would have also scored a 36 in our study. Strong scores but neither better than our top performers. The National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) has some interesting research and programming for sitting and aspiring directors who wish to be best in class. We strongly recommend that hospitality directors take a leading role in the association and making governance at the forefront of their responsibilities.
Tags: board performance,
aethos consulting group,
“I enjoy starting new business ventures. That is why I joined my colleagues at AETHOS Consulting Group. They are highly motivated professionals who care about the success of their clients. I’m an outcome driven executive, who gets graded on results. I don’t make excuses and I play to win. I also believe that understanding cultural differences is the key to success in today’s business world.”
With nearly 30 years of experience in the hospitality industry, Keith is a career hospitality executive. Having graduated from the Cornell University Hotel School, he went on to work at Waldorf=Astoria Hotel before embarking upon a career in hospitality executive search. He was the CEO & founder of HVS Executive Search before joining AETHOS Consulting Group. A frequent lecturer on industry related issues, Keith has written more than 100 articles on the topics of executive selection, pay-for-performance, corporate governance and executive leadership. He is currently writing his first book, The Loneliness of Leadership.
Contact: Keith Kefgen
+1 (718) 313-9149
Georgi’s 30 year career has taken her from New York to the Middle East and, more recently, to the Asia Pacific region. Her global hospitality experience includes hotel and restaurant management; strategic, financial, marketing and operations advisory; asset management; and principal investment and private equity. The breadth and diversity of her business acumen spans from corporate governance working with and on boards to strategic planning for family-owned business and not-for-profit organizations.
A common thread throughout Georgi’s career in the hospitality industry has been her passion for training, coaching, teaching, corporate ethics and sustainability. As a world traveler, avid reader and well-connected hotelier, she continues to stay on top of the trends and best practices that
drive the hospitality industry at all levels.
A graduate of Cornell University’s School of Hotel Administration, she also holds an MBA from Northwestern University’s Kellogg School of Management. She has authored several hospitality-related articles, been quoted in trade publications, taught hospitality courses and guest lectured at New York University, Columbia University, and the Cornell-Nanyang Institute of Hospitality Management, and spoken at several real estate and hotel conferences.
Contact: Georgianne Fsadni
CEO Pay in Gaming: Founders vs Corporate Executives
Why ‘Heart and Soul’ Is Also a Strength in Leadership
The “TRICK” to Navigating the Turbulent Seas of Transition: Traditional Lodging Makes Waves on the High Seas, Part II
Excuses are For Losers: Leadership Involves Pressure and Personal Sacrifice
AETHOS and 20|20 AssessSM Call for Participants in a Recruiting Game-Changer: Identifying Employees with the “X Factor”
Entrepreneurs’ Corner: In Conversation With Nikolai Jaeger, An Innovative Modular Hotel Real Estate Developer
Isn’t “Success” the Ultimate Sign of a True Leader?
The Uberisation of Employment
Introducing the “FAIR” Interview – Four Traits Critical for Success in a Meritocracy
Hasn’t the “Great Man or Woman” Leader Profile Been Debunked as a Myth?
AETHOS Consulting Group Releases Corporate Governing Practices Report: Insights on Hospitality Governance in an Ever-Changing Political Landscape
Corporate Governance in the Hospitality and Gaming Sectors in a Changing Political Landscape
Leadership; "Debunking a Myth" & "The Importance of Communication"
The Sad Side of Valentine’s Day – What the Hospitality Industry Should Know
Hershey Entertainment & Resorts CEO Bill Simpson on Tradition and Technology in Business
A 21st Century Quandary: Pause To Assimilate But Never Stop Running
"What Millennials Want” – The Real Career Priorities of Gen X vs Gen Y
Nominee for “2016 Hospitality Leader of the Year”
Please login or register to post a comment.