Fear and/or Innovation in Hospitality?
August 29, 2017 11:43am
by Georges Panayotis
According to Machiavelli, there are two major motives that make men act: fear and innovation. Today, hoteliers are living up to the rule. As new concepts abound, traditional players have entered a veritable competition to integrate (and take over) innovations launched by innovative start-ups. And this is good since the practices of yesteryear are no longer. It is not a reform, it is a revolution, one that is cultural and affecting the economic model, and it will have to be accomplished by all the actors without exception.
The hotel industry has experienced several blows in recent years: while the finance industry impoverished it with cash extraction and rate increases that degraded its competitiveness, digital technology gnawed away at its margins… and then the sharing economy put the very core of its offer in question by offering accommodations to overnight visitors. The sector shown with a thousand lights, and attracted predators like a light bulb attracts moths. Where there is a herd, there will be shearers and those that eat the herd, said Bakounine…
And yet, it is necessary to accept the idea that innovation may come from external sources. After all, the start-ups and new technology giants that have upset the industry do no less than what Conrad Hilton and John Willard Marriott accomplished in the United States and the Dubrule and Pélisson team did in Europe when they launched hotel chains.
In order to move forward, hoteliers need to make way for innovation driven by new players. In the automobile sector, where technological disruption (Tesla) and changing habits (Uber, Lyft…) are also very strong, traditional actors no longer hesitate to change their business models: Volvo will only develop electric or hybrid vehicles, BMW is partnering with Intel and Fiat Chrysler to develop autonomous vehicles… With the enormous sums at stake to absorb technological developments, and considering the end consumer's interest in having compatible systems, automobile groups are quick to gather around shared platforms. It may be necessary one day for hotel groups to also stop staring icily at one another, while they scream bloody murder at Airbnb, Booking and other innovators.
It will also be important for them to recognize that boundaries between different sectors of activity have become obsolete. When Amazon buys Whole Foods, Ford develops a prototype for a baby bed that rocks newborns to imitate a ride in the car, it is because their technologies and their respective know-how offer them a capacity to innovate and legitimacy in areas that may be new, but fit their DNA. Innovation has become transversal. This means that tomorrow’s competitors will surely hail from other sectors.
The first challenge is to maintain a strong position and values. “Fruit and nothing else”, says the slogan of a successful fruit juice brand… Indeed, while price and location were key to yesterday’s success stories, the product must also play an important role in the strategy.
Since increasing their prices to serve financiers and digital players while salvaging their operating accounts, hoteliers have sacrificed their competitiveness. Who suffered? Consumers first, then (when they rebelled) small franchise owners and hotel personnel, and tomorrow the government once the industry has completed the necessary restructuring –and job destruction inherent to such restructuring. Disinflation, and in some cases deflation, is the only option.
Within this context very few strategies are truly winning. A first, indispensable one, will be to launch new concepts with an attractive quality price ratio to freshen the supply. Another strategy will be to invest heavily to modernize non-competitive assets and put them back on the market. The real question is who will finance that, but that’s another matter.
Finally, there is a third option: take advantage of “nearly zero marginal cost” that has been theorized by Jeremy Rifkin, this innovation doesn’t cost more to produce since it is already developed. Is that enough to rent out a room once a day (or night, in our business)? Aren’t some travelers ready to share a room under certain conditions (think of the credo of Joe Gebbia, cofounder of Airbnb: “design for trust”)? Is the room’s space or that of the common areas (working and F&B areas) used efficiently, particularly outside sleeping hours? Remember: from Uber to Airbnb including new players, all great successes in the sharing economy were built on untapped existing customer bases, extracted from consumer habits in the old economy. The wealth of tomorrow will rise out of the best use of today’s assets.
The good news is that everyone can innovate, from the biggest global groups to the smallest independent hotel in the middle of the desert. There is always a fount somewhere …
Tags: georges panayotis
Georges Panayotis is President of MKG Consulting. Born in a family of hoteliers for three generations, Georges Panayotis, left Greece at the age of 18 to pursue his studies in Political Sciences and to obtain his Master in Management at the French University of Paris Dauphine. He then joined the Novotel chain, which will become the Accor Group, to manage the International Marketing Division. After developing specific marketing tools for the hotel industry, he left the group in 1986 to start his own company, MKG Conseil, now MKG Group. In twenty years, the group has become the European leader in studies and consulting for the Hospitality industry. The company employs over 70 people in four departments: marketing studies, database, quality control and trade press, with two publications HTR Magazine and Hotel Restaurant Weekly.
The company helped the development of over 2,000 hotels in France and in Europe, with offices in Paris, Cyprus and London. Georges Panyotis is the founder of the Worldwide Hospitality Awards and the Hotel Makers Forum, and the author of several publications on Marketing and Operations in the hotel business, He is a regular consultant for several television channels, among which Bloomberg Television, and radio networks.
Contact: Georges Panayotis
Craving M&Ms! Brand, Management, and Strategy
Hotel Supply in France: Nothing Begets Nothing
Make the Hotel the Most Beautiful Place on Earth…Opportunities to Seize!
In Europe, We Made A "Bang" but It Wasn't "Big"
French Hotels & Restaurants: Fruit Bearing Trees Must Be Tended To!
Unlearning to Learn Also Means Inventing
Rights Need a Helping Hand
Innovation in Hospitality: Change is Good
Renovate to Innovate
Pulling on the Grass Won't Make It Grow...
L'Envie D'Avoir Envie, or the Desire to Desire: The Johnny Syndrome
Trip Advisor: The Fox Who Believed Himself Judge
When Everything Is Worthwhile, Nothing Is...
Hospitality Is and Will Remain a Heartfelt Industry
Hotel Industry Pillars: You Sleep, You Dine
Supply and Demand Policy: The Destination Alone will Decide
Fracture, Rupture, Humanity – The Image of Hospitality
Can We Control Our Own Fate? Hospitality Education and Corporations Will Have to Change Significantly
All Forces That Do Not Respect the Law Become Tyrannical
Loss of Productivity: When CAPEX and Management Make No Sense...
Please login or register to post a comment.